I wanted to title this "Why Weight Watchers isn't stupid,
but you might be...." I realize that this post is controversial and it sounds harsh. Not everyone will agree. Most will relate and the rest can just go on in denial...or else agree and not care. I'm not saying that what I'm about to call out on a multi-million dollar company is anything other than observations...but it makes sense to me so it might just make sense to someone else too. Yes, I have attended Weight Watchers meetings some time ago. Yes, I lost weight while under their influence. No, it didn't radicalize my life. Thank God I escaped before I became Lifetime {which is the highest achievement you can gain, earning you the right to go for free --
as long as you weigh in once a month and don't go over their guidelines...Now, isn't
that the freedom you always hoped for???}
Weight Watchers is a company which bases the values of food on POINTS, or Points Plus, or whatever they're calling it these days. The way they assess foods and give values to them was perhaps the most revealing when we had these cardboard sliders {a couple "programs" ago} that had you identify fat, calories, and fiber. You would adjust the inner piece of the slide
just so, so that when everything lined up, the Point value would be revealed. This isn't the case now. Now there is an unknown type of science behind their points {which seemingly changes every year like clock work} to which you have to use a calculator in order to configure what you're eating to their point standards. You are given daily points based on how much you weigh every week. Along with that, you have a weekly
"allowance" and can
earn points through activity. There is NO specific science on how much of your allowance you can/should eat and if you ask if you're
activity points should be banked or consumed you're either going to get mixed reviews from leader to leader or else expect to hear a choir of crickets!
I would really like to punch Weight Watchers in the face for their methodology. I could write a multi-page report breaking down how they are robbing people by "helping" them get their life back or achieve "better health" all while living in a real world. It's crap. Absolute garbage, for the most part.
But, I realize it is one of the better programs out there and I'll tell you who needs it and why:
1. People who have
no clue how to eat at all and are starting from the world of constant convenience foods and Twinkies...oh, wait, we don't have those anymore?....okay, Snickers. The program will introduce you to food groups and give you an idea of how they should fit into your day. However, you are still free to eat however and wherever. I've never once heard discussed the dangers of various chemicals found in fast foods or artificial sweeteners or just how addictive sugars really are.
~But, come on! In the world we live in today, with all the healthy advocating and education, you have to have been living in a cave on a mountain to not have a clue about the trash you consume. There are so many flaws from the "all you can eat fruit" to the lack of standards and training within their leadership.
2. People who have
no support. Weight Watchers offer meetings for people to attend too. You walk in the door and straight to a scale where you pay way too much money to have a receptionist weigh you {insert whatever unfiltered remarks you may encounter here} and have it logged. If you had a good week, you may earn a sticker {yippee!} or a charm of some sort. You'll get recognized in front of the crowd and possibly share straight from your lips what made you successful. Some people need that attention, they thrive off of the "atta girl" and the sheer attention is enough to keep them going. For them, the support is needed and it's good.
Are you starting from ignorance or have zero people in your life who will support you? Do you want to keep eating the regular crap that's been killing you and be told "It's okay as long as you eat an unknown scientifically based number of points?" Then Weight Watchers is for you!
The Dangers of Weight Watchers -in my honest opinion.
1. Your daily Points are too low. One person overheard a leader saying that the minimum they were eating {26 points} was "like 1,100 calories or something." HEAR ME -That's not healthy for
anyone. Not only do some people only eat these minimum points, but they don't dip into their weekly allowance and they certainly don't touch activity points. This is very scary. This is what keeps Weight Watchers in business. Why? Because you lose the weight by starving yourself and then when you finally realize you're hungry or else you reach goal and want to eat "normal," the weight comes back on! Your body is finally getting what it deserves and it's not going to let it go! Normal does not = counting points and fearing monthly weigh ins for the rest of your life.
If you choose the Weight Watcher way, I think you can avoid this by 1.
Eating all your points. Divide your weekly allowance up and
consume every bit of it. C'mon! Think back to being a kid--you couldn't wait to spend your allowance! 2. If you exercise more than 3 days a week,
start eating back your earned points too. Don't fall into the I-want-to-lose-weight-fast-so-I'll-eat-minimal trap! You can't win, but Weight Watchers can --they keep you and your money coming this way.
~OR~
You can
save yourself time and money and count CALORIES and other macros. These are the only "points" that really matter. Learn the REAL value of food. Look at ingredients listed on the package. Are there 6 or less? Get concerned about the chemicals you're consuming rather than "Is it worth 'X' amount of points?" Good health and nutrition will come by being aware of these things, not just leaving it up to a company who derives it's success off of making obese people dependent on them.
Try these free apps/websites:
My Fitness Pal or
Spark People. There is support and accountability as well as food and weight logs offered through both these sites. I've used them both, but currently use My Fitness Pal. You can adjust all the goals on My Fitness Pal yourself.
Don't even rely on the website's minimal goals but use a non-biased
calculator {want to know what you need for daily minimum, select "sedentary" after inputting your personal data. Allow it to calculate. Then, go back and select your actual activity level to see the difference} and always shoot for eating at the top of your range! If you don't find yourself losing weight, then drop by 200 calories for 2 weeks and see how that goes or increase your activity. And, for goodness sake if/WHEN you're going to work out
FEED your muscles!
2. Exercise is discussed, not taught. Huge lack of direction. What you will commonly hear about is walking. Weight Watchers will occasional bring in chefs to teach how to cook healthy meals, but how about bringing in a running coach or certified trainer? You've gotta have both. Some "fat" people are in better shape than their thinner friends simply because they MOVE! I'm afraid many of the Weight Watcher graduates are nothing more than a smaller version of their once overweight selves, better known as "skinny-fat" people.
Weight Watchers isn't stupid. They know exactly what they are doing. They know how to breed temporary success so that you need them for the long term. I chose to step away from it and exchange it for REAL freedom. I learned REAL values of foods. Not just nutrients, but also to begin looking at what it is I'm actually consuming. It's been a slow process, but through practice I have gained victory from the sugar addiction and the crap foods I once consumed under the pre-tense that it was still "okay" because it fit into a point system or the thinking that I had "earned it" because I ran 10 miles when it actually had no place or value in my life. Guess what? After 2 years my weight has not suffered a bit. By God's grace, I am stronger, more educated, and
healthier than I've ever been. And, I don't owe a single bit of that success to a company whose only goal is to keep you coming back for a LIFETIME.